World: r4wp
[Ann-Reply] Reply to Announce group
older newer | first last |
GrahamC 24-May-2013 [1989x3] | I was parsing your mdp docs to convert to epub and found some have authors or not, dates or not, tables were done differently etc |
Robert, you've uploaded the reactors documentation ... but I was under the impression reactors have been removed! | |
So, shouldn't we just delete that reactor stuff? | |
Robert 24-May-2013 [1992x2] | MDP style: Well, we need a pretty printer ;-) |
Reactors: I just packed everything on the docs dir we have as a start. So, yes, we need to sort it out, get rid of the old stuff etc. So feel free to delete it and send a pull-request. | |
GrahamC 24-May-2013 [1994] | And is there any point in uploading the html docs? Since they have to be generated |
Robert 24-May-2013 [1995] | No, as said I just used the docs dir and didn't went through it. Well, seems next time we prepare it a bit better. |
GrahamC 24-May-2013 [1996x2] | Ok, I'll figure out how to send a pull request on these |
As long as other people agree .. it would be painful for you to have to update the html docs each time the mdp ones are changed | |
Robert 24-May-2013 [1998] | This coult be done with a commit hook on our side, but yes, HTML is not needed. |
GrahamC 24-May-2013 [1999x3] | Looks like a number of other docs are not there. |
validation-proposal, dialog-system, gob-capture, save-state etc | |
or I just missed seeing where they are :( | |
Gregg 26-May-2013 [2002] | Thanks for noting the blog update Petr. Nice to hear he's enjoying himself so much. Maybe we'll get him back into REBOL when he sees that he can build Roku stuff in Red. |
Pekr 26-May-2013 [2003] | Well, I wish him well too. OTOH he contradicts himself. He says, he is interested in Rebol, yet he is addicted in something completly else, not finding free time for rebolling. I hope you will meet him at Devcon, so that he gets excited about Rebol againt too :-) |
Gregg 26-May-2013 [2004x2] | I don't think it's contradictory. He focuses deeply on one thing at a time, and everything else is lucky to get any time at all. It's just that now, Roku is his focus. |
OTOH, his work there may lead to new thoughts for REBOL and other languages targeted at small devices in a networked world. | |
Kaj 26-May-2013 [2006] | It's a bit odd that his creation is so fantastic that he can't use it |
GrahamC 26-May-2013 [2007] | Perhaps it was never designed to be use in memory constrained embedded devices |
Kaj 26-May-2013 [2008] | Perhaps it was never designed to be used? |
GrahamC 26-May-2013 [2009] | I smell a troll |
Kaj 26-May-2013 [2010] | I smell excuses |
Pekr 26-May-2013 [2011] | I think that reason for not using R3 is not technology related. Carl even talked about it in the past, that - maybe one day. Imo the reason is two-three-fold - 1) RT's failure, to set up R3 in the wild, business wise 2) at the time Carl joined Roku, R3 was not open-sourced. 3) I also remember, that on R3 Chat, he asked about Gstreamer. So imo even a toolset problem - R3 lacking extensions to popular subsystems, and also risky situation - what if Carl would decide to leave the company? Who would work with his R3 code? |
Kaj 27-May-2013 [2012] | Agreed |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2013] | Seems like I missed the chance to join the chat with Carl and you guys on StackOverflow, but I was in my dreams (or nightmare about autorelease). ;) |
GrahamC 28-May-2013 [2014x2] | Well, you need to be prepared and have sufficient reputation on SO. It took Carl nearly 45 minutes before he was able to speak! |
It was somewhat frustrating for all of us waiting. | |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2016] | Any reason he doesn't wanna do such limited time chats here? |
GrahamC 28-May-2013 [2017x2] | probably hasn't got altme installed |
He said he would only use r3chat before .. but he says that the SO chat is very nice and usable from a browser | |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2019x2] | Yeah, I just remembered, he said something about being able to chat from any computer. |
How hard can it be to create a terminal version of AltME? Well... | |
GrahamC 28-May-2013 [2021] | that is R3 chat |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2022] | But is that usable with e.g. this world? If yes, then he could just use that and join a chat here, couldn't he? |
GrahamC 28-May-2013 [2023x2] | not with this world |
I think he's had world changing experience working at Roku :) | |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2025] | So How hard can it be to create a terminal version of AltME? Well... |
GrahamC 28-May-2013 [2026] | An event driven terminal?? |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2027x2] | No, an interface to this world, but from a text terminal. Like R3 chat, but which actually work with AltME worlds. |
If he did that, he could join this world from any computer. | |
GrahamC 28-May-2013 [2029] | perhaps he doesn't want to |
Oldes 28-May-2013 [2030] | fine.. so after 45min of waiting, what he said instead of a note, that SO chat is nice? |
Pekr 28-May-2013 [2031x2] | Well, I have mixed feelings ... Carl simply gave up on Rebol and its message imo ... felt strange: " I'm no longer in the mode of convincing the world about Rebol. I've learned a lot over the last couple years in the trenches." ..... later .... "So, I know really well now that Rebol is not for every developer.... but it would get more interest if R3+GUI was easy to download an get running on a variety of those devices on your list." |
As for why he does not use R3 at Roku, he confirmed that it might be difficult to mix various IPs of several companies .... | |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2033] | @Pekr, do you think, that's the full story? |
Pekr 28-May-2013 [2034] | I don't know, what do you mean? Full story of what? Well, maybe I will say it arrogantly - but Carl faced the reality we all were facing in our companies - if your tool does not fit the company's toolset, you might be tolerated, if it is open sourced or free. I remember my issues with my boss, trying to convince him why should I buy /Command to get access to shell and ODBC, if other free tools can do it. And that was it - REBOL lived in isolation and Carl, joining Roku, found out about the outer world working under different conditions of reality :-) |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2035] | So less of "mix various IPs". |
Pekr 28-May-2013 [2036] | I expect so, but that is just my speculation .... |
Geomol 28-May-2013 [2037x2] | I got the same feeling. |
But you see, since Carl is the creator of REBOL and has access to the sources, the situation is different than with you and your boss. | |
older newer | first last |