World: r3wp
[!RebGUI] A lightweight alternative to VID
older newer | first last |
Reichart 27-Dec-2007 [7235] | I will prep up some logos, and a few alternative treatments. You can actually simply take anything you like from Quilt. The art is not complete, let alone finished. Meaning, I have to go clean everything up in the next 30 days. The art is being designed to allow several concepts: - Faster rendering through HTML. - Ability to change the colour theme with nothing more than a few simple CSS changes (o art changes). For example, the Search icon is really a white magnifying glass, with a Knock out (alpha channel). This way, the Search input and button are nothing more than a table with a cell with a green outline, and a box that is solid green. Add the small image and presto, custom widget. One can simply change the colour for a new look. |
Robert 28-Dec-2007 [7236x3] | radio-group: Ashley, take a look at my version. It has a default option. |
Icons: At least for icons you can take a look at www.istockphoto.com. I use this services to get high-quality pictures for presentations etc. There are a lot of artists doing icon-sets etc. | |
Costs are $1 or $2 for a download. | |
Ashley 28-Dec-2007 [7239] | For good, free icons I go here: http://tango.freedesktop.org/Tango_Desktop_Project |
Reichart 28-Dec-2007 [7240x2] | I use famfamfam.com for all the small icons. Hard to beat them. I tried sending him money, but he never responded. The icons are free, but I wanted to give him a gift. |
www.famfamfam.com | |
Geomol 28-Dec-2007 [7242] | Reichart, I see a "Make A Donation" button near the bottom of http://www.famfamfam.com/lab/icons/silk/ Did you try that? |
Reichart 28-Dec-2007 [7243] | That is recent...(and good to hear from you) |
Geomol 28-Dec-2007 [7244] | Good to see you're back here too. I had about the most busiest months in my life with studies and work. It's not healthy to be so busy. "More REBOL programming" should be my new year wish (or promise) no. 1. :) |
Brock 28-Dec-2007 [7245] | I'll second Reichart's words. Nice to see some of the newer big names in Rebol appear here again. Maybe we'll see some of the original big names come back when R3 is made public. |
Graham 30-Dec-2007 [7246] | Can get-values be made to work on the contents of a scroll-panel? |
Ashley 30-Dec-2007 [7247] | Noted. |
Pekr 31-Dec-2007 [7248x2] | Dunno if something changed for Sheet widget, but cell borders are somehow too bright here, almost invisible. Can that be set? Hmm, in rebdoc it is a bit darker or maybe my eyes are too tired already :-) What color does it use for borders? |
Ashley - will sheet and tree-view support at least keyboard basics? | |
Ashley 31-Dec-2007 [7250] | What color does it use for borders? ... none, it's transparent. will sheet and tree-view support at least keyboard basics? sheet already supports tab, tree at present has no keyboard support. These are on the "things I'd like to improve one day if I have nothing better to do" list. ;) |
Pekr 31-Dec-2007 [7251x3] | none? transparent? Aha, so if I see "grid lines", it means it comes from background color, right? |
You know, Ashley, there are several measures to UI and its usability. I noticed that ppl really warry, some do most of the things using mouse, and then RebGUI is 98% correct (no scroll-wheel support here or there, area not being able to auto-scroll when hiliting). But those used to keyboard, are suffering much more pain. And believe me - although I can understand minimalistic aproach to RebGUI (and it really feels better than VID2 in almost all aspects), in the end, if widget "missbehaves", I really don't care that, if it is 6KB or 12KB - all I care is - does it behave as expected? | |
well, I believe some of the small details can be fixed. I could easily name them, list them here, if it would help to answer us, what is fixable, and what is not (e.g. due to View inefficiency in particular area) | |
Ashley 31-Dec-2007 [7254] | Providing keyboard support for inherently graphical controls (e.g. radio-group, spinner, etc) is IMHO a waste of time. All the main input widgets (field, edit-list, area, sheet, etc) should and do have proper keyboard support. If you're designing an application for fast data entry then you should confine your widgets to those that accept keyboard input (i.e. data entry forms). If you want a rich GUI with a full set of graphical widgets then I don't think it's too much to ask that users have a pointing device. I mean, you don't expect users to use Windows without a mouse? Or Office type applications? But, list away as I'm currently doing major code fixes (better scroll-wheel support for one) anyway; if it's relatively straight-forward to do I'll do it. |
Pekr 31-Dec-2007 [7255x3] | List of some inefficiencies of RebGUI - decide what could be fixed with no significatn effort (e.g. widget redesign or particular subsystem redesign (tabbing)) 1) no keyboard navigation to swith between the tabs (ctrl + tab) 2) no default focus on page? (maybe just not defined in tour.r), but if there is e.g. table, I would expect it being in-focus, so that keyboard immediatelly works without the need to click the table 3) are othere elements tabbable? I noticed that e.g. on tab with sheet demo, buttons are tabbable. IMO there should be also one primary element selected as being "in-focus", it should be reflected in UI, or I regard it being faulty. 4) sheet widget - define ENTER action doing the same as TAB action. Enhancement request (not necessarily needed) - ability to define tab/enter movement direction - vertical vs horizontal. 5) menu - when mouse moves, menu should collapse/expand upon the movement, not needing 2 clicks (to collapse old position menu, and another click to open one - please reduce at least to one click) 6) tree-view - add arrow support 7) area - hilite by mouse or keyboard should auto-scroll area 8) state elements - add tabbing support with visual reflection - imo you are wrongly assuming, that users might not use keyboard here (space selects) |
btw - what is the graphing widget you liked from Robert's distro? Is it any different from what is in tour.r? Is there any screenshot? :-) | |
As to my above requests - those don't add features, but fixing them would greatly enhance usability. Users are imo forgivable to how app looks, but not how app behaves ... | |
Graham 31-Dec-2007 [7258x2] | i would like to be able to use a tab as a tab inside an area widget. |
And not tab to the next widget. | |
Reichart 31-Dec-2007 [7260x2] | Should RebUI do anything that Windows and Mac don't? Seems there are going to be places where a cool widget would save space, or allow for a neat trick, but............it also means something most people won't know or understand. |
For example, radio buttons are the core of: Radio buttons - O Apple | O Pear | O Banana Tabs - Are just radio buttons where the selection IS the card /Apple\ /Pear\ /Banana\ Combo-box - [_Apple_[^v] Then there was a button on the Amiga which was really cool (spinner?), but never caught on. Every time you clicked on it cycled to the next option in the list. Spinner - [_Apple_[O] This widget is very useful for toggles, and perhaps even up to three states, but after that is loses its value. | |
Gregg 31-Dec-2007 [7262] | ROTARY is the VID equivalent of spinner. view layout [rotary data [a b c]] |
Reichart 31-Dec-2007 [7263] | Gregg, what are your thoughts on this widget even existing? |
Gregg 31-Dec-2007 [7264] | I rarely use it. Because you can't see all the values it's not as user friendly IMO, though it is space efficient. For small displays I can see it being better than a drop-down in some cases. |
Henrik 31-Dec-2007 [7265] | it would be more efficient, if you could use the mouse to drag left and right with mouse button held down to browse between many values. |
Anton 31-Dec-2007 [7266] | If there is a big delay selecting elements then combo-box is better because you don't have to move through all intermediate elements. If there is no delay then the spinner is good too. |
Graham 31-Dec-2007 [7267x3] | Is the original data block for a tree available? I wish to traverse the tree and prevent users from adding duplicate leaves |
there are no accessors to add leaves? Does set-data work? | |
Nope. | |
Ashley 31-Dec-2007 [7270] | Is the original data block for a tree available? yes, as face/data there are no accessors to add leaves? correct, it's a very basic widget at this stage Does set-data work? ... only from within init at present |
Graham 31-Dec-2007 [7271x2] | face/data just gives the currently selected node |
Hmm. Anyway of refreshing the tree to show a new node/leaf?? | |
Ashley 31-Dec-2007 [7273] | Not at present. When I said face/data before I meant widget/data. |
Graham 31-Dec-2007 [7274] | So, I have to recreate the whole layout for tab in order to refresh the tree ? |
Ashley 31-Dec-2007 [7275] | i would like to be able to use a tab as a tab inside an area widget. That would be kind of confusing. Imagine a display with a couple of fields and an area ... I hold down the tab key and suddenly I've navigated to the area *and* inserted a couple of tabs. Wouldn't a "special" key combination suchh as CTRL-Tab be better? |
Graham 31-Dec-2007 [7276x4] | well, I think I would more often use a tab inside an area, then tab thru one. |
So, I would prefer ctrl-tab to exit an area .... | |
I think it's un-natural to use cntrol-tab inside an area to get a tab. | |
what do other gui's do? | |
Anton 31-Dec-2007 [7280x2] | ctrl+tab can work in linux but not in Windows. |
(unless you find some way to capture ctrl+tab in Windows) | |
Graham 31-Dec-2007 [7282] | shift tab? |
Anton 31-Dec-2007 [7283x2] | For edit-panel, I thought ctrl+tab would be ideal for jumping out to other widgets and then can continue to tab as normal. |
but the question is how to capture it on Windows. | |
older newer | first last |