World: r3wp

the second example, both skip ARE evaluated, thus it returns true.

Maxim, you are a very patient teacher.

:-)  I missed such a big feature of rebol for sooo long, just because 
I didn't get these nuances.  and its hard to make a tutorial out 
of this, cause it sooooo boring, and you don't realize why its so 
important until you really start to use parse.

btw, I keep logging off, cause the winds are wreaking havoc on the 
electricity lines!  there is probably a loose connector on some junction 
and my whole house has rebooted at least 15 times in the last 2 hours 
 :-/

I agree, it needs to be interactively taught. I know I will still 
get it wrong, but I fee more confident to analyse what is going wrong 
now.

wow, are you still in the winter? Are you in Canada?

all of northern usa should be affected the same way, it snowed yesterday 
in central canada!  yet we are already at temperatures of 65-70 on 
average... its just clash of northern and southern winds... creating 
a massive disruption here.

Hi, I am after some advice on creating a data structure please.
I read data from my file in this sort of order.
disabled
2/34
2/35

vlan 3
2/35
2/48

vlan 5
2/3
2/24

name
2/1 name one
2/35 second name

Then I want to export it in this sort of format.
port <tab> disabled <tab> vlan <tab> name 
2/1                                  name one
2/3                        5
2/24       disabled
2/34                       5
2/35       disabled        3         second name
2/48                       3


I am hoping that I can create a structure that mimics the data its 
self.
maybe like
data/2/35/disabled = "disabled"
data/2/35/vlan = "3"
data/2/35/name = "second name"


Then some how use the input data to define what part of the structure 
the item is recorded in.

Once I have it in a structure like this I am expecting it to be simple 
to enumerate each part to do my export.

Use blocks.

>> data: [[] [[vlan 3]]]
== [[] [[vlan 3]]]
>> data/2/1/vlan
== 3

And then probably PARSE should be used to scan the input and put 
values in the data block structure (maybe building the structure 
along the way, if it's known beforehand).

if it's *not* known beforehand

That looks exactly the structure I had in mind, but how do I get 
the data into the right part of the structure?
if I have data of   3 2/1 & I know it refers to a vlan.
I will have up to about 1500 of these for each file

If there can only be two indexs into the data, you setup those indexs, 
when you scan input. Something like (pseudo code):

vlan: 3
idx1: 2
idx2: 1
data/:idx1/:idx2/vlan: vlan


If you don't have the full data structure before you start, you might 
have to check like:


if idx1 > length? data [ ... create the required blocks inside data 
...]

if idx2 > length? data/:idx1 [ ... create the required blocks inside 
data/:idx1 ...]

That would mean I read the input repeatedly (up to about 400 times) 
for each input wouldnt it?

sorry, secont part of your message answers that option

:-)

You can also do it without using PARSE, if that's too much to start 
with. Read the input as lines with READ/LINES
A line could then be:

line: "vlan 3"

And you can pick the parts with something like:

>> copy/part line find line " "
== "vlan"
>> next find line " "
== "3"


Using PARSE is the elegant way to do it, but can be a bit tricky, 
until you've used it a few times.

or use parse line " ", which will return block of "words"

In fact I do know the index structure, so your first example is exactly 
what I need.   :-)

How do I get the data back out of this structure please?  I dont 
understand all the colons in it.

The input data is the result of a lot of parsing.

If you use integers and words as your indexâÊyou don't have colon, 
like in:

data/2/35/vlan


If you have a variable with the index, you need the colon to get 
the value of the variable, else REBOL will see it as a word, like 
in:

idx1: 2
idx2: 35
data/:idx1/:idx2/vlan

If you write

data/idx1/idx2/vlan

REBOL will look for the word idx1 in data, and it's not there.

I can't get it to work. 
>> data/1/2/vlan: 3
** Script Error: Cannot use path on none! value
** Near: data/1/2/vlan: 3

Has you defined data?

Have

I dont know how to

I have tried data: []

data: [ [ [] [vlan 0] ] ]

Your data has nothing in it. To be able to write

data/1/2/vlan: 3


you need to have at least one entry in data, and inside that two 
entries and inside that the word vlan and a value.

so I need to define all possiable parts of the structure before I 
use it.

eh ... yes or


build the structure along the way as you pointed out, the second 
part of my answer was about.

from data/1/1/vlan   to data/12/48/name  that sounds a bit tricky.

Programming can be tricky.

:-)

I tried to create a data structure like this

i2: [[vlan []][disabled []][name []]]

i1: [[i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2]]
data:[[i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1]]

but when I try to use the structure I get
data/1/3/vlan: 3
** Script Error: Cannot use path on none! value
** Near: data/1/3/vlan: 3

Have I just made a typo?  or am I barking up the wrong tree?

you've just got blocks of unevaluated blocks ( all containing the 
identical block )

create a Rebol object! instead

is an object less tricky to define?

you will have fewer problems

you need to create your data structures or objects and then probe 
them to make sure you have it right.

I have done this
template: make object! [
i2: reduce [[vlan 0][disabled " "][name " "]]

i1: reduce [[i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2][i2]]

data: reduce [[i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1][i1]]
]
record: make template []

 probe record/data/13/48  returns none ol
but >> probe record/data/13/48/vlan
** Script Error: Cannot use path on none! value

do I need to do somthing to make it construct deeper levels?

Have you read this ?  http://www.rebol.com/docs/core23/rebolcore-10.html

Was looking at it, yes. but not discoverd how these deep nested levels 
work yet.

well, one way would be to create the top level object and then add 
the other objects to the first object's members

oh, nest objects inside each other.  I will try that. Thanks.

in the above, you're expecting 20 - 30 copies of i2, but you're going 
to get all of them exactly the same ....

ie. they won't be different but all will reference the same block

Now if i2 were an object, you need to instantiate 30 instances and 
append each instance to the i1 member

That was not what I inteded..  Thanks for pointing that out...  I 
am out of my depth at the moment.

well, I think you need to work with a few small examples .. as what 
you're doing is way out ...

ok, this is a reduced set...  but it does not work. I wonder if I 
have a problem with context?

PortAttributesObj: make object! [

 vlan: copy []     ;; will hold a number or perhaps a list of numbers 
 e.g. 20 or 3,5,7
	UpState: copy []  ;; none or "disabled"
	name: copy []     ;; any string
]

PortNumberObj: make object! [
	p1: make PortAttributesObj []
	p2: make PortAttributesObj []
	p3: make PortAttributesObj []
	p4: make PortAttributesObj []
;; so on up to
	p48: make PortAttributesObj []
]

ModuleNumberObj: make object! [
	m1: make ModuleNumberObj []
	m2: make ModuleNumberObj []
	m3: make ModuleNumberObj []
;; so on up to
	m13: make ModuleNumberObj []
]	

record: make ModuleNumberObj []